Solver Square Comparison: Considers all models.

Date / Time: 08/02/02 14:16:33
System info: GAMS Rev 133 Jun 14, 2002 WIN.00.NA 20.7 133.000.040.VIS P3 translator


Solver comparison utility.

Compares all solver return outcomes (for example optimal, infeasible, unbounded, interrupt, fail) of one solver with all return outcomes of another solver. Interrupt denotes resource or iteration limit has been reached. Solver CONOPT1 is represented on the left (rows) and solver CONOPT2 on top (columns). See the solver return definitions for return codes.


Tracefile 1 :copstest.co1
Tracefile 2 :copstest.co2
Solvers used : CONOPT1
CONOPT2
Modeltype(s)   NLP



optimal feasible infeasible unbounded fail total CONOPT1
optimal - - - - - -
feasible - 52 - - 8 60
infeasible - - - - - -
unbounded - - - - - -
fail - 4 - - 2 6
total CONOPT2 - 56 - - 10 66




Solver return definitions:

OutcomeModel StatusSolver Status
optimal 1 or 15 1
feasible 2 or 16 or 17 1 or 2 or 3
infeasible4 or 5 or 19 1
unbounded3 or 18 1
fail all other all other




Solver Resource Times


CONOPT1 : feas -- CONOPT2 : feas    Back to top

Modelname CONOPT1 CONOPT2 Ratio (CONOPT1/CONOPT2) Obj (CONOPT1) Obj (CONOPT2)
POLYGON_75 10.1992 19.7109 0.517 0.78434698 0.78458532
POLYGON_100 31.4180 47.0586 0.668 0.78483498 0.78472646
ELEC_25 0.1094 0.1523 0.718 243.81276030 243.81276030
CHAIN_50 0.5000 0.0508 9.846 5.07226427 5.07226149
CHAIN_100 2.0000 0.1094 18.286 5.06978462 5.06978461
CHAIN_200 2.8906 0.6406 4.512 5.06897116 5.06891735
CHAIN_400 12.4492 1.2227 10.182 5.06879982 5.06862170
CAMSHAPE_100 0.0938 0.0703 1.333 4.28414711 4.28414712
CAMSHAPE_200 0.4297 0.1602 2.683 4.27850002 4.27850023
CAMSHAPE_400 1.6016 0.3711 4.316 4.27568558 4.27568848
CAMSHAPE_800 7.0898 2.4102 2.942 4.27419342 4.27427414
PINENE_25 0.7383 1.0000 0.738 19.87153306 19.87153211
PINENE_50 2.0313 1.7813 1.140 19.87216601 19.87216552
PINENE_100 33.0508 5.2500 6.295 104.12733979 19.87217014
PINENE_200 28.8711 13.7891 2.094 19.87216680 19.87216685
POPDYNM_25 2.8086 3.1719 0.885 19752215.41511080 19752215.41510830
POPDYNM_50 5.4492 6.0195 0.905 19746545.15628000 19746545.15627980
POPDYNM_100 16.5508 16.1719 1.023 19746528.60226940 19746528.60217240
POPDYNM_200 50.9805 38.5703 1.322 19746529.64661190 19746529.64660500
FLOWCHAN_50 0.1602 0.0977 1.640 0.00000000 0.00000000
FLOWCHAN_100 0.3984 0.1797 2.217 0.00000000 0.00000000
FLOWCHAN_200 1.2227 0.3711 3.295 0.00000000 0.00000000
FLOWCHAN_400 4.5781 0.7500 6.104 0.00000000 0.00000000
ROBOT_50 0.4805 0.1992 2.412 9.14687850 9.14687850
ROBOT_100 3.0781 0.9414 3.270 9.14268538 9.14268538
ROBOT_200 18.8398 3.8594 4.882 9.14139550 9.14139550
ROBOT_400 82.0000 18.1406 4.520 9.14102603 9.14102603
LNTS_50 0.1289 0.1211 1.065 0.55466878 0.55466876
LNTS_100 0.3906 0.3906 1.000 0.55459557 0.55459540
LNTS_200 2.3398 2.0078 1.165 0.55457755 0.55457702
LNTS_400 13.3906 10.5195 1.273 0.55457318 0.55457241
ROCKET_50 0.4414 0.5000 0.883 1.01277879 1.01281710
ROCKET_100 1.6992 2.7813 0.611 1.01274140 1.01283184
ROCKET_200 7.7500 7.0703 1.096 1.01263736 1.01283543
ROCKET_400 31.9180 31.6602 1.008 1.00557048 1.01283647
GASOIL_50 0.2813 0.3281 0.857 0.00523672 0.00523664
GASOIL_100 0.6602 0.7227 0.914 0.00523667 0.00523659
GASOIL_200 1.4102 1.6211 0.870 0.00523667 0.00523660
GASOIL_400 2.9609 3.3203 0.892 0.00523667 0.00523660
METHANOL_50 0.2617 0.3633 0.720 0.00902229 0.00902229
METHANOL_100 0.5508 0.7813 0.705 0.00902229 0.00902229
METHANOL_200 1.1406 1.9414 0.588 0.00902229 0.00902229
METHANOL_400 2.3906 4.0586 0.589 0.00902229 0.00902229
CATMIX_100 0.0625 0.2188 0.286 -0.04803191 -0.04806939
CATMIX_200 0.1172 0.5313 0.221 -0.04801351 -0.04805891
CATMIX_400 0.3594 1.0391 0.346 -0.04800442 -0.04805616
CATMIX_800 1.4492 2.7500 0.527 -0.04792936 -0.04805502
TORSION_51_26 6.7773 9.8281 0.690 -0.41751072 -0.41751073
TORSION_51_51 167.7500 90.6602 1.850 -0.41808763 -0.41808763
TORSION_51_76 584.7500 540.2305 1.082 -0.41819940 -0.41819940
JBEARING_51_76 226.5469 218.5117 1.037 -0.15498446 -0.15498453
JBEARING_51_101 402.9805 492.4180 0.818 -0.15504189 -0.15504196

Back to top





CONOPT1 : feas -- CONOPT2 : f    Back to top

Modelname CONOPT1 CONOPT2 Ratio (CONOPT1/CONOPT2) Obj (CONOPT1) Status (CONOPT2)
ELEC_50 1.3438 0.7500 --- 1055.18231475 mstat( 7) sstat( 1)
ELEC_100 5.9414 6.8008 --- 4448.35063438 mstat( 7) sstat( 1)
JBEARING_51_26 14.1406 17.4219 --- -0.15401553 mstat( 7) sstat( 1)
JBEARING_51_51 60.7500 89.4414 --- -0.15482420 mstat( 7) sstat( 1)
MINSURF_51_26 9.5977 14.2383 --- 2.51948769 mstat( 7) sstat( 1)
MINSURF_51_51 57.1719 87.0898 --- 2.51488920 mstat( 7) sstat( 1)
MINSURF_51_76 176.6992 252.5117 --- 2.50568659 mstat( 7) sstat( 1)
MINSURF_51_101 414.2617 600.4531 --- 2.50694942 mstat( 7) sstat( 3)

Back to top





CONOPT1 : f -- CONOPT2 : feas    Back to top

Modelname CONOPT1 CONOPT2 Ratio (CONOPT1/CONOPT2) Status (CONOPT1) Obj (CONOPT2)
GLIDER_50 0.4375 6.6914 --- mstat( 6) sstat( 5) 1282.39972360
GLIDER_100 1.9883 21.5273 --- mstat( 6) sstat( 5) 1254.61354071
GLIDER_200 10.0703 69.8906 --- mstat( 6) sstat( 5) 1248.89636213
GLIDER_400 27.8086 249.4805 --- mstat( 6) sstat( 5) 1247.97431754

Back to top





CONOPT1 : f -- CONOPT2 : f    Back to top

Modelname CONOPT1 CONOPT2 Ratio (CONOPT1/CONOPT2) Status (CONOPT1) Status (CONOPT2)
ELEC_200 31.6602 65.3203 --- mstat( 7) sstat( 1) mstat( 7) sstat( 1)
TORSION_51_101 600.5000 600.3789 --- mstat( 7) sstat( 3) mstat( 7) sstat( 3)

Back to top





CONOPT1 : feas:     Back to top

Modelname CONOPT1 Obj (CONOPT1)
POLYGON_75 10.1992 0.78434698
POLYGON_100 31.4180 0.78483498
ELEC_25 0.1094 243.81276030
ELEC_50 1.3438 1055.18231475
ELEC_100 5.9414 4448.35063438
CHAIN_50 0.5000 5.07226427
CHAIN_100 2.0000 5.06978462
CHAIN_200 2.8906 5.06897116
CHAIN_400 12.4492 5.06879982
CAMSHAPE_100 0.0938 4.28414711
CAMSHAPE_200 0.4297 4.27850002
CAMSHAPE_400 1.6016 4.27568558
CAMSHAPE_800 7.0898 4.27419342
PINENE_25 0.7383 19.87153306
PINENE_50 2.0313 19.87216601
PINENE_100 33.0508 104.12733979
PINENE_200 28.8711 19.87216680
POPDYNM_25 2.8086 19752215.41511080
POPDYNM_50 5.4492 19746545.15628000
POPDYNM_100 16.5508 19746528.60226940
POPDYNM_200 50.9805 19746529.64661190
FLOWCHAN_50 0.1602 0.00000000
FLOWCHAN_100 0.3984 0.00000000
FLOWCHAN_200 1.2227 0.00000000
FLOWCHAN_400 4.5781 0.00000000
ROBOT_50 0.4805 9.14687850
ROBOT_100 3.0781 9.14268538
ROBOT_200 18.8398 9.14139550
ROBOT_400 82.0000 9.14102603
LNTS_50 0.1289 0.55466878
LNTS_100 0.3906 0.55459557
LNTS_200 2.3398 0.55457755
LNTS_400 13.3906 0.55457318
ROCKET_50 0.4414 1.01277879
ROCKET_100 1.6992 1.01274140
ROCKET_200 7.7500 1.01263736
ROCKET_400 31.9180 1.00557048
GASOIL_50 0.2813 0.00523672
GASOIL_100 0.6602 0.00523667
GASOIL_200 1.4102 0.00523667
GASOIL_400 2.9609 0.00523667
METHANOL_50 0.2617 0.00902229
METHANOL_100 0.5508 0.00902229
METHANOL_200 1.1406 0.00902229
METHANOL_400 2.3906 0.00902229
CATMIX_100 0.0625 -0.04803191
CATMIX_200 0.1172 -0.04801351
CATMIX_400 0.3594 -0.04800442
CATMIX_800 1.4492 -0.04792936
TORSION_51_26 6.7773 -0.41751072
TORSION_51_51 167.7500 -0.41808763
TORSION_51_76 584.7500 -0.41819940
JBEARING_51_26 14.1406 -0.15401553
JBEARING_51_51 60.7500 -0.15482420
JBEARING_51_76 226.5469 -0.15498446
JBEARING_51_101 402.9805 -0.15504189
MINSURF_51_26 9.5977 2.51948769
MINSURF_51_51 57.1719 2.51488920
MINSURF_51_76 176.6992 2.50568659
MINSURF_51_101 414.2617 2.50694942

Back to top





CONOPT1 : f:     Back to top

Modelname CONOPT1 Status (CONOPT1)
ELEC_200 31.6602 mstat( 7) sstat( 1)
GLIDER_50 0.4375 mstat( 6) sstat( 5)
GLIDER_100 1.9883 mstat( 6) sstat( 5)
GLIDER_200 10.0703 mstat( 6) sstat( 5)
GLIDER_400 27.8086 mstat( 6) sstat( 5)
TORSION_51_101 600.5000 mstat( 7) sstat( 3)

Back to top





CONOPT2 : feas:     Back to top

Modelname CONOPT2 Obj (CONOPT2)
POLYGON_75 19.7109 0.78434698
POLYGON_100 47.0586 0.78483498
ELEC_25 0.1523 243.81276030
CHAIN_50 0.0508 5.07226427
CHAIN_100 0.1094 5.06978462
CHAIN_200 0.6406 5.06897116
CHAIN_400 1.2227 5.06879982
CAMSHAPE_100 0.0703 4.28414711
CAMSHAPE_200 0.1602 4.27850002
CAMSHAPE_400 0.3711 4.27568558
CAMSHAPE_800 2.4102 4.27419342
PINENE_25 1.0000 19.87153306
PINENE_50 1.7813 19.87216601
PINENE_100 5.2500 104.12733979
PINENE_200 13.7891 19.87216680
POPDYNM_25 3.1719 19752215.41511080
POPDYNM_50 6.0195 19746545.15628000
POPDYNM_100 16.1719 19746528.60226940
POPDYNM_200 38.5703 19746529.64661190
FLOWCHAN_50 0.0977 0.00000000
FLOWCHAN_100 0.1797 0.00000000
FLOWCHAN_200 0.3711 0.00000000
FLOWCHAN_400 0.7500 0.00000000
ROBOT_50 0.1992 9.14687850
ROBOT_100 0.9414 9.14268538
ROBOT_200 3.8594 9.14139550
ROBOT_400 18.1406 9.14102603
LNTS_50 0.1211 0.55466878
LNTS_100 0.3906 0.55459557
LNTS_200 2.0078 0.55457755
LNTS_400 10.5195 0.55457318
ROCKET_50 0.5000 1.01277879
ROCKET_100 2.7813 1.01274140
ROCKET_200 7.0703 1.01263736
ROCKET_400 31.6602 1.00557048
GLIDER_50 6.6914 1004.52693604
GLIDER_100 21.5273 1002.35218302
GLIDER_200 69.8906 1001.02797167
GLIDER_400 249.4805 993.83894909
GASOIL_50 0.3281 0.00523672
GASOIL_100 0.7227 0.00523667
GASOIL_200 1.6211 0.00523667
GASOIL_400 3.3203 0.00523667
METHANOL_50 0.3633 0.00902229
METHANOL_100 0.7813 0.00902229
METHANOL_200 1.9414 0.00902229
METHANOL_400 4.0586 0.00902229
CATMIX_100 0.2188 -0.04803191
CATMIX_200 0.5313 -0.04801351
CATMIX_400 1.0391 -0.04800442
CATMIX_800 2.7500 -0.04792936
TORSION_51_26 9.8281 -0.41751072
TORSION_51_51 90.6602 -0.41808763
TORSION_51_76 540.2305 -0.41819940
JBEARING_51_76 218.5117 -0.15498446
JBEARING_51_101 492.4180 -0.15504189
POLYGON_25 0.4727 0.00000000
POLYGON_50 3.3867 0.00000000

Back to top





CONOPT2 : f:     Back to top

Modelname CONOPT2 Status (CONOPT2)
ELEC_50 0.7500 mstat( 7) sstat( 1)
ELEC_100 6.8008 mstat( 7) sstat( 1)
ELEC_200 65.3203 mstat( 7) sstat( 1)
TORSION_51_101 600.3789 mstat( 7) sstat( 3)
JBEARING_51_26 17.4219 mstat( 7) sstat( 1)
JBEARING_51_51 89.4414 mstat( 7) sstat( 1)
MINSURF_51_26 14.2383 mstat( 7) sstat( 1)
MINSURF_51_51 87.0898 mstat( 7) sstat( 1)
MINSURF_51_76 252.5117 mstat( 7) sstat( 1)
MINSURF_51_101 600.4531 mstat( 7) sstat( 3)

Back to top