Resource Times:   Considers only models solved optimal/feasible by both solvers.

Date / Time: 01/22/03 11:07:46


Total resource time for models solved optimal/feasible by solver A and solver B.

See the solver return definitions for optimal/feasible model and solve statuses. Solutions are not checked for how close they are to oneanother. Resource times are considered the same, if they are within 10% of eachother. A solver is considered faster than another, if it is less than 50% faster than the other. A solver is considered much faster than another, if it is more than 50% faster than the other.

A solver is considered to have a better objective function value, if the relative objective value difference is greater than 1.00E-05. For objective values below 1e-1 we use absolute differences.

Tracefile 1 :trace1.trc
Tracefile 2 :trace2.trc
Solvers used : A
B
Modeltype(s)   LP


Total Obj. A better Obj. same Obj. B better
Solver A much faster : 12 - 12 -
Solver A faster : 39 - 38 1
Solvers perform the same: 120 - 119 1
Solver B faster : 205 - 205 -
Solver B much faster : 66 1 65 -
Total models solved optimal/feasible : 442 1 439 2




Solver return definition:

OutcomeModel StatusSolver Status
globally optimal 1 or 15 1
locally optimal/feasible 2 or 16 or 17 1 or 2 or 3 or 4 or 5




Resource Times:

Resource times (as in trace file) listed in seconds.


Back to top

Solver A much faster - Obj same for both solvers:

Modelname A B Ratio (A / B)Obj AObj B
dbic1 2709.740012338.79000.220 -9.76897300E+06 -9.76897300E+06
dbir1 77.5600847.15000.092 -8.10670700E+06 -8.10670701E+06
dbir2 96.3200223.12000.432 -6.11691650E+06 -6.11691654E+06
fome20 900.91002525.52000.357 2.38216586E+10 2.38216586E+10
p010 4.280017.61000.243 1.11504792E+06 1.11504792E+06
pds-06 10.960034.45000.318 2.77610376E+10 2.77610376E+10
pds-10 46.6100104.16000.447 2.67270950E+10 2.67270950E+10
pds-20 861.22002497.24000.345 2.38216586E+10 2.38216586E+10
pldd000b 0.43001.15000.374 2.74328127E+00 2.74328127E+00
r05 2.65007.18000.369 5.57831859E+05 5.57831859E+05
rlfprim 502.44001042.04000.482 1.00000000E+00 9.99999953E-01
scrs8-2r-512 1.91005.21000.367 1.07409934E+03 1.07409934E+03

Back to top



Back to top

Solver A faster - Obj same for both solvers:

Modelname A B Ratio (A / B)Obj AObj B
aa3 39.450047.29000.834 4.96163636E+04 4.96163634E+04
aa6 21.430024.80000.864 2.69771875E+04 2.69771875E+04
air02 1.66001.90000.874 7.64000000E+03 7.64000000E+03
co5 39.680051.00000.778 7.14469554E+05 7.14469554E+05
complex 18.160027.15000.669 -9.96666667E+01 -9.96666667E+01
delf025 4.23005.27000.803 3.50296809E+02 3.50296809E+02
delf026 3.83004.93000.777 3.51613348E+02 3.51613348E+02
delf028 4.17005.33000.782 2.97245644E+02 2.97245644E+02
delf029 4.77006.65000.717 2.75225649E+02 2.75225649E+02
etamacro 0.08000.09000.889 -7.55715232E+02 -7.55715233E+02
fome21 5405.50008802.39000.614 4.73463189E+10 4.73463189E+10
israel 0.05000.06000.833 -8.96644822E+05 -8.96644822E+05
mod2 252.0300341.19000.739 2.77373729E+07 2.77373714E+07
nl 37.720064.53000.585 1.22926401E+06 1.22926401E+06
nsir1 4.73006.23000.759 -2.89090330E+07 -2.89090330E+07
nw14 30.690041.32000.743 6.18440000E+04 6.18439994E+04
osa-30 15.730018.08000.870 2.14213987E+06 2.14213987E+06
osa-60 58.300068.22000.855 4.04407250E+06 4.04407250E+06
p05 1.84002.99000.615 5.56000277E+05 5.56000277E+05
p19 0.07000.11000.636 2.49976175E+05 2.49976175E+05
pldd001b 0.73001.23000.593 3.81137208E+00 3.81137208E+00
pldd003b 1.03001.28000.805 4.03488835E+00 4.03488835E+00
pldd004b 0.90001.10000.818 4.18220322E+00 4.18220322E+00
pldd006b 1.11001.34000.828 4.18242877E+00 4.18242877E+00
pldd007b 0.92001.26000.730 4.04383771E+00 4.04383771E+00
pldd008b 1.05001.18000.890 4.17214557E+00 4.17214557E+00
pldd010b 1.21001.41000.858 4.82759155E+00 4.82759155E+00
pldd011b 1.04001.25000.832 4.96812558E+00 4.96812558E+00
qiulp 0.48000.65000.738 -9.31638845E+02 -9.31638846E+02
rlfddd 21.240034.88000.609 -1.30000008E+01 -1.30000044E+01
scfxm1-2b-4 0.11000.13000.846 2.87598336E+03 2.87598336E+03
scrs8-2r-256 0.80001.17000.684 1.14416062E+03 1.14416062E+03
scsd8-2r-64 0.93001.40000.664 1.58427500E+01 1.58427500E+01
sctap1-2r-16 0.08000.09000.889 3.59000000E+02 3.59000000E+02
small012 0.11000.14000.786 6.23062303E-01 6.23062303E-01
small013 0.10000.12000.833 9.63047583E-01 9.63047583E-01
small014 0.11000.14000.786 1.22984037E+00 1.22984811E+00
world 318.7400481.00000.663 4.03648741E+07 4.03648731E+07

Back to top



Back to top

Solver A faster - Obj of B better:

Modelname A B Ratio (A / B)Obj AObj B
co9 185.8200338.97000.548 9.46951429E+05 9.46920430E+05

Back to top



Back to top

Solvers perform the same - Obj same for both solvers:

Modelname A B Ratio (A / B)Obj AObj B
aa03 65.610066.11000.992 4.96163634E+04 4.96163610E+04
aa4 17.320017.86000.970 2.58776093E+04 2.58776093E+04
adlittle 0.02000.0100--- 2.25494963E+05 2.25494963E+05
afiro 0.01000.0100--- -4.64753143E+02 -4.64753143E+02
agg 0.04000.0300--- -3.59917673E+07 -3.59917673E+07
agg2 0.07000.07001.000 -2.02392524E+07 -2.02392524E+07
air06 65.730069.04000.952 4.96163634E+04 4.96163610E+04
beaconfd 0.03000.0100--- 3.35924858E+04 3.35924858E+04
blend 0.01000.0100--- 0.00000000E+00 0.00000000E+00
boeing2 0.04000.0200--- -8.72872880E+02 -8.72872880E+02
bore3d 0.02000.0200--- 1.37308039E+03 1.37308039E+03
brandy 0.03000.0400--- 1.51850990E+03 1.51850990E+03
capri 0.06000.02003.000 2.69001291E+03 2.69001291E+03
cq5 42.200039.41001.071 4.00133807E+05 4.00133807E+05
cq9 208.0100229.88000.905 5.05541720E+05 5.05541710E+05
cr42 0.42000.40001.050 2.80185002E+01 2.80185002E+01
d6cube 26.300029.16000.902 3.15491666E+02 3.15491666E+02
degen3 4.09004.32000.947 -9.87294000E+02 -9.87294000E+02
delf012 3.94003.69001.068 1.78680059E+02 1.78680059E+02
delf014 4.01004.29000.935 1.53498546E+02 1.53498552E+02
delf020 3.75003.58001.047 3.51681256E+02 3.51681256E+02
delf030 4.00004.01000.998 2.53840223E+02 2.53840223E+02
deter7 5.86006.13000.956 -2.22856799E+00 -2.22856798E+00
deter8 2.11002.17000.972 -2.79429548E+00 -2.79429547E+00
disp3 0.25000.25001.000 1.83887522E+05 1.83887522E+05
e226 0.07000.04001.750 -1.87519291E+01 -1.87519291E+01
farm 0.01000.0000--- 1.75000000E+04 1.75000000E+04
finnis 0.06000.04001.500 1.72791066E+05 1.72791066E+05
flugpl 0.01000.0100--- 1.16718573E+06 1.16718573E+06
gams10a 0.02000.0100--- 1.00000000E+00 1.00000000E+00
gams30a 0.03000.0100--- 1.00000000E+00 1.00000000E+00
gfrd-pnc 0.03000.0300--- 0.00000000E+00 0.00000000E+00
greenbea 8.57008.16001.050 -7.25552390E+07 -7.25552481E+07
jendrec1 57.610059.94000.961 7.02846051E+03 7.02846051E+03
kb2 0.02000.0200--- -1.74990013E+03 -1.74990013E+03
kleemin3 0.01000.0100--- -1.00000000E+04 -1.00000000E+04
kleemin4 0.00000.0100--- -1.00000000E+06 -1.00000000E+06
kleemin5 0.01000.0100--- -1.00000000E+08 -1.00000000E+08
kleemin6 0.01000.0100--- -1.00000000E+10 -1.00000000E+10
kleemin7 0.01000.0000--- -1.00000000E+12 -1.00000000E+12
lotfi 0.02000.0200--- -2.52647061E+01 -2.52647061E+01
maros-r7 20.690018.83001.099 1.49718517E+06 1.49718517E+06
model1 0.03000.0300--- 0.00000000E+00 0.00000000E+00
multi 0.01000.0000--- 4.39049117E+04 4.39049117E+04
nemswrld 434.6200451.35000.963 2.60308965E+02 2.60308966E+02
nsic1 0.05000.04001.250 -9.16855400E+06 -9.16855400E+06
nsic2 0.06000.04001.500 -8.20351200E+06 -8.20351200E+06
nug05 0.05000.03001.667 5.00000000E+01 5.00000000E+01
nug07 1.68001.69000.994 1.47999998E+02 1.47999998E+02
orswq2 0.01000.0100--- -1.84585023E-01 -1.84585023E-01
osa-14 6.91006.61001.045 1.10646284E+06 1.10646284E+06
p0040 0.02000.0000--- 6.17965451E+04 6.17965451E+04
p0291 0.02000.0300--- 1.70512876E+03 1.70512876E+03
p6000 0.84000.85000.988 -2.35187133E+06 -2.35187133E+06
pilot4 0.31000.32000.969 -2.58113926E+03 -2.58113926E+03
pldd002b 1.22001.23000.992 4.06513093E+00 4.06513093E+00
pldd005b 1.10001.15000.957 4.15399262E+00 4.15399262E+00
pldd009b 1.24001.28000.969 4.54319571E+00 4.54319571E+00
pldd012b 1.28001.27001.008 4.61332933E+00 4.61332933E+00
problem 0.01000.0100--- 4.83012197E-08 0.00000000E+00
recipe 0.00000.0000--- -2.66616000E+02 -2.66616000E+02
refine 0.01000.0000--- -3.92691800E+05 -3.92691800E+05
sc105 0.01000.0100--- -5.22020612E+01 -5.22020612E+01
sc205-2r-16 0.02000.0200--- -5.53877140E+01 -5.53877140E+01
sc205-2r-27 0.02000.0400--- -1.51057402E+01 -1.51057402E+01
sc205-2r-32 0.05000.03001.667 -5.53877140E+01 -5.53877140E+01
sc205-2r-4 0.00000.0000--- 0.00000000E+00 0.00000000E+00
sc205-2r-8 0.02000.0100--- -6.04229607E+01 -6.04229607E+01
sc205 0.02000.0200--- -5.22020612E+01 -5.22020612E+01
sc50a 0.01000.0100--- -6.45750771E+01 -6.45750771E+01
sc50b 0.01000.0000--- -7.00000000E+01 -7.00000000E+01
scagr25 0.06000.06001.000 -1.47534331E+07 -1.47534331E+07
scagr7-2b-4 0.01000.0200--- -8.32941327E+05 -8.32941327E+05
scagr7-2c-4 0.02000.0200--- -8.32260034E+05 -8.32260034E+05
scagr7-2r-4 0.01000.0200--- -8.32902151E+05 -8.32902151E+05
scagr7-2r-8 0.03000.0300--- -8.32902151E+05 -8.32902151E+05
scagr7 0.02000.0100--- -2.33138982E+06 -2.33138982E+06
scfxm1 0.06000.04001.500 1.84167590E+04 1.84167590E+04
scorpion 0.04000.0200--- 1.87812482E+03 1.87812482E+03
scrs8-2b-16 0.03000.0200--- 1.12104276E+02 1.12104276E+02
scrs8-2b-4 0.00000.0000--- 1.12104275E+02 1.12104275E+02
scrs8-2c-16 0.03000.0200--- 1.12431726E+02 1.12431726E+02
scrs8-2c-32 0.05000.04001.250 1.12156236E+02 1.12156236E+02
scrs8-2c-4 0.01000.0100--- 1.12104275E+02 1.12104275E+02
scrs8-2c-8 0.03000.0200--- 1.12415909E+02 1.12415909E+02
scrs8-2r-16 0.02000.0200--- 1.23176565E+02 1.23176565E+02
scrs8-2r-27 0.04000.0200--- 5.87166361E+02 5.87166361E+02
scrs8-2r-32 0.05000.03001.667 1.23176565E+02 1.23176565E+02
scrs8-2r-4 0.01000.0100--- 1.23176565E+02 1.23176565E+02
scrs8-2r-8 0.02000.0100--- 1.12297084E+03 1.12297084E+03
scsd1 0.05000.03001.667 8.66666581E+00 8.66666667E+00
scsd8-2b-4 0.04000.0100--- 1.52500000E+01 1.52500000E+01
scsd8-2c-4 0.03000.0200--- 1.50000000E+01 1.50000000E+01
scsd8-2r-4 0.03000.0200--- 1.55000000E+01 1.55000000E+01
scsd8-2r-8 0.08000.03002.667 1.60000000E+01 1.60000000E+01
scsd8-2r-8b 0.08000.04002.000 1.60000000E+01 1.60000000E+01
sctap1-2b-4 0.01000.0200--- 2.39250000E+02 2.39250000E+02
sctap1-2c-4 0.02000.0200--- 2.36250000E+02 2.36250000E+02
sctap1-2c-64 0.67000.66001.015 2.00390625E+02 2.00390625E+02
sctap1-2r-27 0.18000.17001.059 2.47500000E+02 2.47500000E+02
sctap1-2r-4 0.03000.0100--- 2.80500000E+02 2.80500000E+02
sctap1-2r-8 0.04000.05000.800 3.60500000E+02 3.60500000E+02
sctap1 0.04000.0300--- 1.41225000E+03 1.41225000E+03
share1b 0.03000.0100--- -7.65893186E+04 -7.65893186E+04
share2b 0.01000.0100--- -4.15732241E+02 -4.15732241E+02
shell 0.08000.08001.000 1.20882535E+09 1.20882535E+09
ship04s 0.06000.06001.000 1.79871470E+06 1.79871470E+06
sierra 0.08000.04002.000 0.00000000E+00 0.00000000E+00
small008 0.14000.13001.077 8.05382599E+00 8.05382599E+00
small009 0.12000.11001.091 4.90813888E+00 4.90813888E+00
small011 0.11000.12000.917 8.86642864E-01 8.86642864E-01
small015 0.10000.10001.000 1.68048743E+00 1.68049312E+00
standata 0.05000.02002.500 1.25769950E+03 1.25769950E+03
standgub 0.05000.02002.500 1.25769950E+03 1.25769950E+03
stocfor1 0.02000.0000--- -4.11319762E+04 -4.11319762E+04
stocfor2 1.14001.08001.056 -3.90244085E+04 -3.90244085E+04
vtp-base 0.02000.0000--- 1.29831462E+05 1.29831462E+05
wood1p 1.37001.24001.105 1.44290241E+00 1.44290237E+00
zed 0.01000.0100--- -1.50606452E+04 -1.50606452E+04

Back to top



Back to top

Solvers perform the same - Obj of B better:

Modelname A B Ratio (A / B)Obj AObj B
cplex2 0.05000.04001.250 6.57048015E-01 6.57027774E-01

Back to top



Back to top

Solver B faster - Obj same for both solvers:

Modelname A B Ratio (A / B)Obj AObj B
25fv47 2.23001.77001.260 5.50184589E+03 5.50184589E+03
aa01 76.850064.23001.196 5.55354361E+04 5.55354362E+04
aa5 41.140032.05001.284 5.37359285E+04 5.37359284E+04
agg3 0.08000.05001.600 1.03121159E+07 1.03121159E+07
aircraft 5.66003.79001.493 1.56704235E+03 1.56704235E+03
bandm 0.07000.05001.400 -1.58628018E+02 -1.58628018E+02
baxter 305.3400262.86001.162 5.60072557E+07 5.60072557E+07
bnl1 0.38000.25001.520 1.97762956E+03 1.97762956E+03
bnl2 1.89001.60001.181 1.81123654E+03 1.81123654E+03
boeing1 0.07000.06001.167 -9.01316377E+02 -9.01316377E+02
cari 4.10002.43001.687 5.81893058E+02 5.81893058E+02
ch 16.400012.90001.271 9.25756370E+05 9.25756370E+05
cre-a 3.12002.11001.479 2.35954071E+07 2.35954071E+07
cre-b 218.7300144.71001.512 2.31296399E+07 2.31296399E+07
cre-c 2.23001.86001.199 2.52751161E+07 2.52751161E+07
crew1 2.43001.32001.841 2.05555556E+01 2.05555556E+01
cycle 0.67000.57001.175 -5.22639302E+00 -5.22639302E+00
czprob 0.52000.29001.793 2.18519670E+06 2.18519670E+06
d2q06c 20.520017.97001.142 1.22784211E+05 1.22784211E+05
de080285 0.33000.25001.320 1.39247329E+01 1.39247329E+01
degen2 0.25000.18001.389 -1.43517800E+03 -1.43517800E+03
delf000 2.07001.46001.418 3.07629839E+00 3.07629839E+00
delf001 2.53001.29001.961 2.35860891E+03 2.35860891E+03
delf002 2.51001.78001.410 2.83275927E+00 2.83276797E+00
delf003 3.33002.10001.586 9.11554518E+03 9.11554518E+03
delf004 3.86002.51001.538 1.58693661E+02 1.58693661E+02
delf005 3.95002.32001.703 2.28730402E+03 2.28730402E+03
delf006 3.96002.46001.610 2.28431143E+02 2.28431143E+02
delf007 4.49002.70001.663 3.79955827E+02 3.79955827E+02
delf008 4.38002.59001.691 2.41235483E+02 2.41235483E+02
delf009 4.64002.89001.606 4.84124788E+02 4.84124788E+02
delf010 4.15002.62001.584 2.29106667E+02 2.29106667E+02
delf011 4.38003.50001.251 4.73494203E+02 4.73494203E+02
delf013 4.13003.45001.197 2.61667692E+03 2.61667692E+03
delf015 3.90002.99001.304 7.37036785E+02 7.37036785E+02
delf017 3.71002.37001.565 4.61518340E+02 4.61518340E+02
delf018 3.83002.31001.658 1.42133863E+02 1.42133863E+02
delf019 3.38002.33001.451 2.34212886E+03 2.34212886E+03
delf021 4.54002.83001.604 3.94704353E+02 3.94704353E+02
delf022 3.71002.84001.306 3.64992928E+02 3.64992928E+02
delf023 3.99003.23001.235 3.54117068E+02 3.54117068E+02
delf024 4.40003.67001.199 3.51416794E+02 3.51416794E+02
delf027 4.74004.17001.137 3.19455577E+02 3.19455577E+02
delf031 4.55003.05001.492 2.34298514E+02 2.34298514E+02
delf032 3.88003.29001.179 2.16039209E+02 2.16039209E+02
delf033 4.09003.20001.278 2.00271651E+02 2.00271651E+02
delf034 4.59003.26001.408 1.89437475E+02 1.89437475E+02
delf035 4.49003.27001.373 1.76948821E+02 1.76948821E+02
delf036 4.16002.83001.470 1.64459309E+02 1.64459309E+02
deter0 0.55000.44001.250 -2.04591961E+00 -2.04591961E+00
deter1 4.69003.53001.329 -2.55756437E+00 -2.55756436E+00
deter2 8.13004.94001.646 -1.82986995E+00 -1.82986994E+00
deter3 10.08005.92001.703 -2.10779073E+00 -2.10779072E+00
deter5 4.60002.84001.620 -2.26122360E+00 -2.26122359E+00
deter6 2.94002.42001.215 -2.30798671E+00 -2.30798670E+00
df2177 15.18009.35001.624 8.99999999E+01 8.99999996E+01
fffff800 0.09000.08001.125 5.55679565E+05 5.55679565E+05
fit1d 0.35000.21001.667 -9.14637809E+03 -9.14637809E+03
fit1p 0.58000.49001.184 9.14637809E+03 9.14637809E+03
fit2d 34.210024.74001.383 -6.84642933E+04 -6.84642933E+04
fit2p 61.490040.58001.515 6.84642933E+04 6.84642933E+04
ganges 0.18000.13001.385 -1.09585736E+05 -1.09585736E+05
greenbeb 7.85006.56001.197 -4.30226026E+06 -4.30226026E+06
grow15 0.36000.19001.895 -1.06870941E+08 -1.06870941E+08
grow22 0.90000.63001.429 -1.60834336E+08 -1.60834336E+08
grow7 0.09000.06001.500 -4.77878118E+07 -4.77878118E+07
haprp 0.12000.10001.200 3.66596321E+06 3.66596321E+06
iiasa 0.25000.18001.389 2.63486121E+08 2.63486121E+08
ken-07 0.37000.24001.542 -6.79520443E+08 -6.79520443E+08
ken-11 9.65005.68001.699 -6.97238226E+09 -6.97238226E+09
kl02 9.64007.18001.343 2.15250000E+02 2.15249999E+02
l9 0.24000.16001.500 9.98235590E-01 9.98235713E-01
large003 7.46004.89001.526 2.45954876E+04 2.45954876E+04
large004 9.42005.53001.703 1.74706315E+02 1.74706315E+02
large005 7.48004.63001.616 4.11852869E+02 4.11852869E+02
large006 9.88004.94002.000 2.47449202E+02 2.47449202E+02
large007 7.89004.41001.789 5.02611533E+02 5.02611533E+02
large008 8.75004.78001.831 2.68113994E+02 2.68113994E+02
large009 8.98005.59001.606 5.02824227E+02 5.02824227E+02
large010 8.72005.52001.580 2.56250339E+02 2.56250346E+02
large011 8.51005.27001.615 4.93584751E+02 4.93584751E+02
large012 7.96005.14001.549 1.99701163E+02 1.99701173E+02
large013 9.24005.09001.815 5.71006217E+02 5.71006219E+02
large015 8.52004.38001.945 6.72530568E+02 6.72530568E+02
large016 8.49005.41001.569 1.63486940E+02 1.63486945E+02
large018 7.42004.02001.846 2.14616510E+02 2.14616510E+02
large020 9.37005.19001.805 3.77518730E+02 3.77518730E+02
large021 10.51006.01001.749 4.22130994E+02 4.22131001E+02
large022 8.02005.30001.513 3.77485426E+02 3.77485436E+02
large023 7.67004.61001.664 3.62446668E+02 3.62446668E+02
large024 10.00007.70001.299 3.56031433E+02 3.56031433E+02
large025 9.64004.97001.940 3.55445962E+02 3.55445962E+02
large026 8.35005.54001.507 3.56375496E+02 3.56375496E+02
large027 8.33005.41001.540 3.33705656E+02 3.33705657E+02
large028 10.42006.31001.651 3.11365057E+02 3.11365057E+02
large030 11.26006.50001.732 2.65125992E+02 2.65125992E+02
large031 10.29005.25001.960 2.45027631E+02 2.45027631E+02
large032 11.26005.72001.969 2.26145590E+02 2.26145590E+02
large033 10.45005.35001.953 2.09838050E+02 2.09838050E+02
large034 10.67005.54001.926 1.98767594E+02 1.98767594E+02
large035 9.00005.26001.711 1.85606648E+02 1.85606648E+02
large036 8.01005.12001.564 1.71065374E+02 1.71065374E+02
lp22 390.0000291.75001.337 4.58944594E+02 4.58944594E+02
maros 0.53000.30001.767 -5.80637437E+04 -5.80637437E+04
model11 34.790026.04001.336 -4.58304891E-08 -2.54545135E-08
model2 0.57000.31001.839 -7.40048910E+03 -7.40048910E+03
model3 5.65002.85001.982 1.74890610E+04 1.74890610E+04
model6 13.86007.41001.870 1.17507692E+05 1.17507692E+05
model9 15.41007.81001.973 -1.41123094E+05 -1.41123094E+05
modszk1 0.21000.11001.909 3.20619729E+02 3.20619729E+02
nemsafm 0.08000.07001.143 -6.79237428E+03 -6.79237428E+03
nemscem 0.15000.13001.154 8.97723335E+04 8.97723335E+04
nemspmm1 29.110015.91001.830 -3.27415836E+05 -3.27415836E+05
nemspmm2 37.900021.50001.763 -2.91794836E+05 -2.91794836E+05
nsct1 44.790024.17001.853 -3.89224360E+07 -3.89224360E+07
nug06 0.34000.17002.000 8.59999999E+01 8.60000000E+01
nug12 654.6600572.49001.144 5.22894342E+02 5.22894345E+02
osa-07 2.81002.27001.238 5.35722517E+05 5.35722517E+05
pcb1000 1.94001.48001.311 5.68094569E+04 5.68094569E+04
pcb3000 10.57009.47001.116 1.37416420E+05 1.37416420E+05
pds-02 0.71000.40001.775 2.88578620E+10 2.88578620E+10
pds-2 0.72000.43001.674 2.88578620E+10 2.88578620E+10
perold 0.85000.69001.232 -9.38075528E+03 -9.38075528E+03
pilot-ja 2.57002.27001.132 -6.11313647E+03 -6.11313647E+03
pilot-we 1.60001.09001.468 -2.72010753E+06 -2.72010753E+06
pilot 28.280023.53001.202 -5.57489706E+02 -5.57489729E+02
pilot87 79.650058.89001.353 3.01710352E+02 3.01710347E+02
pilotnov 1.57001.10001.427 -4.49727619E+03 -4.49727619E+03
progas 1.03000.87001.184 7.60773215E+05 7.60773215E+05
qap08 8.05005.87001.371 2.03500000E+02 2.03499999E+02
qap12 693.6500534.23001.298 5.22894346E+02 5.22894348E+02
rail507 67.420050.10001.346 1.72145567E+02 1.72145567E+02
rail516 30.640022.28001.375 1.82000000E+02 1.82000000E+02
rail582 91.100056.40001.615 2.09712233E+02 2.09712233E+02
rat1 5.27002.88001.830 1.99953166E+06 1.99953166E+06
rat5 11.41008.82001.294 3.08370701E+06 3.08370701E+06
rat7a 110.900075.73001.464 2.07437142E+06 2.07437142E+06
rosen1 1.60000.85001.882 -2.76127367E+04 -2.76127367E+04
rosen10 16.03009.08001.765 -1.74215456E+05 -1.74215456E+05
rosen7 0.17000.10001.700 -2.03297018E+04 -2.03297018E+04
rosen8 1.03000.56001.839 -4.21226795E+04 -4.21226795E+04
route 144.8600109.63001.321 5.94164950E+03 5.94165014E+03
sc205-2r-100 0.39000.21001.857 -1.00704935E+01 -1.00704935E+01
sc205-2r-50 0.11000.06001.833 -3.07641141E+01 -3.07641141E+01
sc205-2r-64 0.15000.09001.667 -5.53877140E+01 -5.53877140E+01
scagr7-2b-16 0.07000.06001.167 -8.32902151E+05 -8.32902151E+05
scagr7-2c-16 0.11000.06001.833 -8.32260034E+05 -8.32260034E+05
scagr7-2r-16 0.08000.05001.600 -8.32902151E+05 -8.32902151E+05
scagr7-2r-27 0.17000.12001.417 -8.33543817E+05 -8.33543817E+05
scagr7-2r-32 0.21000.13001.615 -8.32902094E+05 -8.32902094E+05
scagr7-2r-54 0.39000.21001.857 -8.33834104E+05 -8.33834104E+05
scfxm1-2c-4 0.17000.09001.889 2.87598336E+03 2.87598336E+03
scfxm1-2r-4 0.15000.13001.154 2.87756386E+03 2.87756386E+03
scfxm1-2r-8 0.36000.29001.241 2.87756386E+03 2.87756386E+03
scfxm2 0.18000.14001.286 3.66602616E+04 3.66602616E+04
scfxm3 0.32000.22001.455 5.49012545E+04 5.49012545E+04
scrs8-2b-64 0.15000.11001.364 1.12145123E+03 1.12145123E+03
scrs8-2c-64 0.13000.10001.300 1.11881190E+02 1.11881190E+02
scrs8-2r-128 0.32000.23001.391 1.17734504E+03 1.17734504E+03
scrs8-2r-64 0.13000.08001.625 1.23176603E+02 1.23176603E+02
scrs8-2r-64b 0.12000.10001.200 1.34609633E+03 1.34609633E+03
scrs8 0.13000.08001.625 9.04296954E+02 9.04296954E+02
scsd6 0.14000.07002.000 5.04999995E+01 5.05000001E+01
scsd8-2c-16 0.15000.09001.667 1.50000000E+01 1.50000000E+01
scsd8-2r-108 2.14001.26001.698 2.36999943E+01 2.36999943E+01
scsd8-2r-54 1.15000.64001.797 2.38499979E+01 2.38499979E+01
scsd8 0.55000.30001.833 9.05000000E+02 9.05000000E+02
sctap1-2b-16 0.12000.07001.714 2.80800000E+02 2.80800000E+02
sctap1-2b-64 15.18007.79001.949 4.84560000E+02 4.84560000E+02
sctap1-2c-16 0.11000.09001.222 3.26400000E+02 3.26400000E+02
sctap1-2r-108 3.50001.89001.852 2.48000000E+02 2.48000000E+02
sctap1-2r-32 0.29000.17001.706 3.54000000E+02 3.54000000E+02
sctap1-2r-480 70.410036.55001.926 2.48500000E+02 2.48500000E+02
sctap1-2r-54 0.60000.46001.304 2.49250000E+02 2.49250000E+02
sctap1-2r-64 0.77000.54001.426 3.44000000E+02 3.44000000E+02
sctap1-2r-8b 0.06000.05001.200 2.50000000E+02 2.50000000E+02
sctap2 0.22000.13001.692 1.72480714E+03 1.72480714E+03
sctap3 0.34000.18001.889 1.42400000E+03 1.42400000E+03
seba 0.09000.06001.500 1.36974000E+04 1.36974000E+04
self 121.620093.30001.304 0.00000000E+00 0.00000000E+00
seymourl 14.27008.28001.723 4.03846474E+02 4.03846474E+02
ship04l 0.12000.09001.333 1.79332454E+06 1.79332454E+06
ship08l 0.42000.21002.000 1.90905521E+06 1.90905521E+06
ship08s 0.10000.08001.250 1.92009821E+06 1.92009821E+06
ship12l 0.49000.27001.815 1.47018792E+06 1.47018792E+06
ship12s 0.18000.13001.385 1.48923613E+06 1.48923613E+06
slptsk 41.760030.20001.383 2.98953660E+01 2.98953660E+01
small000 0.14000.08001.750 2.12826714E+01 2.12827229E+01
small001 0.12000.10001.200 2.00763247E+03 2.00763250E+03
small002 0.22000.16001.375 3.76576400E+01 3.76576400E+01
small003 0.16000.12001.333 1.85436829E+02 1.85436838E+02
small004 0.15000.13001.154 5.46844311E+01 5.46844415E+01
small005 0.16000.12001.333 3.41716251E+01 3.41716898E+01
small006 0.17000.13001.308 2.44313369E+01 2.44313473E+01
small007 0.13000.11001.182 1.38824592E+01 1.38824697E+01
small010 0.13000.10001.300 2.26291090E+00 2.26291090E+00
small016 0.10000.09001.111 2.20308600E+00 2.20308945E+00
south31 500.8800326.84001.532 1.81894020E+09 1.81894020E+09
stair 0.18000.11001.636 -2.51266951E+02 -2.51266951E+02
standmps 0.06000.05001.200 1.40601750E+03 1.40601750E+03
t0331-4l 483.5700289.50001.670 2.97300334E+04 2.97300334E+04
truss 20.020010.46001.914 4.58815847E+05 4.58815847E+05
tuff 0.11000.06001.833 2.92147765E-01 2.92147765E-01
ulevimin 837.6400484.16001.730 -5.19110186E+09 -5.19110186E+09
us04 17.790011.95001.489 1.77316664E+04 1.77316656E+04

Back to top



Back to top

Solver B much faster - Obj of A better:

Modelname A B Ratio (A / B)Obj AObj B
lpl2 2.33001.14002.044 4.46491577E+03 4.46500002E+03

Back to top



Back to top

Solver B much faster - Obj same for both solvers:

Modelname A B Ratio (A / B)Obj AObj B
80bau3b 10.66004.52002.358 9.87224192E+05 9.87224192E+05
bas1lp 42.310020.98002.017 3.63000000E+02 3.63000000E+02
car4 12.39005.42002.286 3.54603702E+01 3.54603702E+01
cep1 1.77000.65002.723 3.55160086E+05 3.55160086E+05
cre-d 186.280092.92002.005 2.44549698E+07 2.44549698E+07
deter4 4.27001.84002.321 -1.42803505E+00 -1.42803505E+00
ge 34.050014.11002.413 5.58128021E+06 5.58128021E+06
gen1 416.8900108.42003.845 7.91835683E-07 -6.52046290E-07
ken-13 144.940043.67003.319 -1.02573948E+10 -1.02573948E+10
ken-18 1755.5600607.27002.891 -5.22170253E+10 -5.22170253E+10
l30 425.3500172.99002.459 9.52646436E-01 9.52649344E-01
large000 7.18003.03002.370 7.26085264E+01 7.26085263E+01
large001 7.01003.00002.337 3.31814155E+04 3.31814155E+04
large002 9.36004.66002.009 2.88151974E+00 2.88151976E+00
large014 9.42004.55002.070 1.71576025E+02 1.71576025E+02
large017 7.64003.49002.189 6.25682740E+02 6.25682739E+02
large019 8.28003.50002.366 5.25527687E+02 5.25527687E+02
large029 11.89005.75002.068 2.87477608E+02 2.87477608E+02
model10 115.010050.28002.287 -1.54599621E+05 -1.54599621E+05
model4 27.32006.39004.275 1.11270245E+06 1.11270245E+06
model5 25.360011.94002.124 -8.58440729E+05 -8.58440729E+05
model7 37.040011.81003.136 4.93800855E+04 4.93800855E+04
model8 2.20000.78002.821 0.00000000E+00 0.00000000E+00
nemsemm1 55.740022.54002.473 5.12959601E+05 5.12959601E+05
nemsemm2 25.700012.76002.014 5.81079571E+05 5.81079571E+05
nesm 2.64001.22002.164 1.40760342E+07 1.40760342E+07
nsct2 71.710021.69003.306 -3.71750820E+07 -3.71750820E+07
nsir2 7.95003.88002.049 -2.71755935E+07 -2.71755935E+07
nug15 13924.75006912.80002.014 1.04099395E+03 1.04099402E+03
pgp2 24.500012.09002.026 4.47324315E+02 4.47324315E+02
primagaz 5.47001.42003.852 1.07190261E+09 1.07190261E+09
rlfdual 519.6500151.67003.426 -1.00000567E+00 -1.00001493E+00
rosen2 6.99003.45002.026 -5.44175098E+04 -5.44175098E+04
sc205-2r-1600 89.930041.21002.182 0.00000000E+00 0.00000000E+00
sc205-2r-200 1.59000.79002.013 -1.00704935E+01 -1.00704935E+01
sc205-2r-400 7.60003.61002.105 -1.00704935E+01 -1.00704935E+01
sc205-2r-800 40.600015.54002.613 -1.00704935E+01 -1.00704935E+01
scagr7-2b-64 15.71002.63005.973 -8.32901548E+05 -8.32901548E+05
scagr7-2c-64 0.63000.27002.333 -8.18719606E+05 -8.18719606E+05
scagr7-2r-108 1.87000.61003.066 -8.34038849E+05 -8.34038849E+05
scagr7-2r-216 8.59002.53003.395 -8.34038849E+05 -8.34038849E+05
scagr7-2r-432 44.07009.25004.764 -8.34029780E+05 -8.34029780E+05
scagr7-2r-64 0.78000.31002.516 -8.32902043E+05 -8.32902043E+05
scagr7-2r-864 196.340040.15004.890 -8.34376099E+05 -8.34376099E+05
scfxm1-2b-16 1.69000.77002.195 2.87756386E+03 2.87756386E+03
scfxm1-2b-64 117.710057.35002.052 2.87756386E+03 2.87756386E+03
scfxm1-2r-128 135.390056.86002.381 2.89170611E+03 2.89170611E+03
scfxm1-2r-16 1.63000.80002.037 2.87756386E+03 2.87756386E+03
scfxm1-2r-256 611.0300260.09002.349 2.89170611E+03 2.89170611E+03
scfxm1-2r-27 4.87001.64002.970 2.88696461E+03 2.88696461E+03
scfxm1-2r-32 6.54002.34002.795 2.87756386E+03 2.87756386E+03
scfxm1-2r-64 29.970011.13002.693 2.87756386E+03 2.87756386E+03
scfxm1-2r-96 71.790033.04002.173 2.89170611E+03 2.89170611E+03
scsd8-2b-16 0.18000.07002.571 2.75000000E+01 2.75000000E+01
scsd8-2b-64 31.25005.90005.297 1.59986677E+01 1.59986680E+01
scsd8-2c-64 75.620016.27004.648 1.49992312E+01 1.49992319E+01
scsd8-2r-16 0.24000.07003.429 1.59995000E+01 1.59995000E+01
scsd8-2r-216 47.85003.250014.723 2.33999837E+01 2.33999839E+01
scsd8-2r-27 0.34000.15002.267 2.40000000E+01 2.40000000E+01
scsd8-2r-32 0.94000.17005.529 1.59989999E+01 1.59990000E+01
scsd8-2r-432 165.360033.68004.910 2.57999692E+01 2.57999694E+01
sctap1-2r-216 14.50006.13002.365 2.49000000E+02 2.49000000E+02
stocfor3 208.690049.23004.239 -3.99767839E+04 -3.99767839E+04
testbig 20.39005.59003.648 -6.04229607E+01 -6.04229607E+01
woodw 2.88001.06002.717 1.30447633E+00 1.30447633E+00

Back to top